joy@sterlingsky.ca

Screenshot 2015-09-27 at 8.46.50 PM

Updated: September 7, 2016 – Duplicates in MapMaker should be reported, not deleted.  Updated what to do with old practitioner listings.

Updated: March 4, 2016 – Added process for marking an old location as moved.

There are so many different scenarios that could exist in the Google My Business (GMB) world when it comes to duplicate listings. The approach you take with them could mean the difference between ranking and not ranking.

Before doing anything listed below, always make sure you check both listings to see if there are reviews that need to be moved.

Listings for Businesses at Physical Locations (Have Storefronts):

  • 2 Listings for the same business at the same address
    • If they are both verified, you will first need to contact Google My Business (GMB) to get ownership of both before they can be merged. The GMB team will have to merge the 2 for you.
    • If only one is verified, go into MapMaker and get the URL for both the verified and the unverified one and write them down (save this somewhere). Go to the unverified listing and click the little drop-down beside the title and select “report this”. For the reason, select “Duplicate Exists” and in the remarks section, clarify that there is a verified duplicate that exists for the business and include a link to the verified listing.
  • 2 Listings for the same business at different addresses
    • If the incorrect address is an old address of the business (they were there at some point in time)
      • Contact Google My Business through Twitter Support (@googlemybiz) and ask them to mark the old listing as moved.
    • If the incorrect address is one that the business has never existed at, go into MapMaker and select “delete this” and then “place does not exist”.

 

Listings for Service Area Businesses (SAB)s Without Storefronts:

  • 2 Listings for the same business at the same address or different addresses
    • If they are both verified, you will first need to contact Google My Business (GMB) to get ownership of both before they can be merged. The GMB team will have to merge the 2 for you.
    • If only one is verified, go into MapMaker and pull up the unverified listing. The verified one shouldn’t show up in MapMaker if the address is properly hidden.  Go to the unverified listing and click the little drop-down beside the title and select “delete this”. For the reason, select “place does not exist” and clarify that this is a service area business and they are not permitted to be listed on the map.

 

*Important Note: Unverified listings for SABs should never be marked closed, they should always be deleted.

Listings for Professionals/Practitioners

  • Public-Facing professionals (doctors, lawyers, dentists, realtors etc) are allowed their own listings separate from the office they work for unless they are the only public-facing professional at that office. In that case, there should only be one listing formatted as “Business Name: Professional Name”
  • If you find an unverified listing for a public-facing professional who no longer works at your location but did at some point, contact GMB support and ask them to mark the listing for the professional that no longer works there as moved to the practice listing. In order to accomplish this, the practitioner listing *must* be unverified. If it’s currently verified you need to get access to it first and delete it from your Google My Business dashboard to make it unverified.  For more details on why it absolutely must be done this way, read my case study here.
  • If a listing exists for an employee who is not public-facing (ex: a hygienist, nurse, or paralegal) or someone who never worked at that address, you should go into MapMaker and select “delete this” and then “other”. In the notes explain why you are deleting it so the person reviewing it can verify the information.

 

Did I miss any scenarios you have come across? Tell me about it in the comments.

 

44 replies on “The Proper Way To Deal with Duplicates in Google My Business”

  • Chris McCreery

    Great post Joy! This definitely helpful for dealing with duplicates in GMB. Many businesses either forget or are totally unaware you can actually call the My Business support folks.

    • Joy Hawkins

      The ironic thing is that calling GMB is actually my last resort. I only listed it as the preferred method for instances where both listings are verified OR if you’re dealing with 1 verified listing + an unverified closed listing (in which case GMB’s method is better for ranking than MapMaker’s method).

      Personally, I’ve found dealing with duplicates within MapMaker as the best option for most cases.

  • Helmut Geissler

    great post Joy

    Hope I can remember it if come across next tim users with duplicates listings

  • Travis Van Slooten

    Joy…you say you mostly use MapMaker. How would you use MapMaker to merge two listings at the same address that are both verified by the owner? Or do these require a phone call to Google?

    Travis

  • 3 Ways to get More Foot Traffic to Your Stores | SweetIQ Blog

    […] getting rid of duplicate listings (Joy Hawkins has a great step-by-step guide on how to do this here), and making sure all the information is complete and correct. Cleaning up your listings for each […]

  • RIP Map Maker Phone Search - Local Dupe Research Just Got A Lot Harder - Page 2

    […] @Matthew – depends on the case. I wrote an article that covers most of the scenarios I've run into. If I left one off, let me know. The Proper Way To Deal with Duplicates in Google My Business […]

  • Automatic Duplicate Google Plus Page

    […] "However, I am bit confused: yesterday I had a talk with Google customer support and they told me that since this page has not been claimed yet, they cannot delete it, and even if they did delete it, the page would automatically create itself again because Google uses users-generated signals." GMB phone reps often forget about mapping rules. SABs are not permitted on the map (https://support.google.com/mapmaker/…/2642650?hl=en). They get added all the time by bots that scrape information so it is possible that this could get added back which is why it's imperative that you go and clean up all the citations around the web that list this address and update it to the one your using in GMB (Commonwealth). The phone rep also might not have noticed this is a service area business. They have different rules than businesses with storefronts. Let me know once you double-check with your client to make sure they don't service clients there. I also put together a guide for dealing with duplicates if you want to check it out: The Proper Way To Deal with Duplicates in Google My Business […]

  • Moving Your Office Without Losing Rankings: The Local Business Owner's Guide

    […] based on old data, and you’ll want to have this on your radar. If you find one, make sure you deal with it the right way. Keep in mind that when you move, Google usually updates the existing listing — it […]

  • SAB Duplicate - How to delete?

    […] The duplicate: https://plus.google.com/114067764956420638436/about I'm following Joy's awesome advice, but can't find the duplicate in MapMaker. There's isn't a full address to search for, or it's […]

  • 5 Major Differences Between Google Map Maker & Google My Business Guidelines

    […] Which is better? I’m still doing testing on this, but so far I’ve found the Map Maker method is better for ranking. When GMB merges two listings, all the information and history from the duplicate is merged, but the data is hidden so you can no longer see what it was. I’ve had situations where this data has overwritten stuff in my dashboard and changed the categories on the listing. Therefore, my current advice is to delete duplicates via Map Maker. […]

  • Dwight Walker

    I had problems because Google did not recognise that a company with Pty Ltd or P/L ending were the same company not 2 companies. My new address was still being listed in my old address on Google Maps. That was fixed by calling Google. Also Google wanted to delete Google+ personal account of myself where I said I worked for my own business andkeep only the business listing not my personal listing on Google+ which I blocked. I am still waiting to see if I can add a category to my business without having to close my Google+ account for myself. This is extreme for 1 person companies like mine.

  • John Taylor

    run a therapy business from two different locations, based from rooms I rent at private clinics. The clinics both have several therapists working from that address. I myself have several ‘brands, so to speak, offering different services to clients with different needs, for example a stop smoking service, a weight loss service, etc… all from the same address. I have created a Google+ Brand page for each of these, and Google+ Location page for each. The reason I want them separate is that the therapies and approaches are not related. They are different techniques that are not necessarily related, and are marketed differently to different audiences. I would like to make sure that I will not be penalised for having several ‘businesses’ running form the same address details. Can someone please advise or point me in the right direction for policy? Many thanks

  • Reid Bandremer

    This has been helpful. Thanks Joy. How would you recommend proceeding if:
    If there are to GMB accounts for a business with a physical location, but only 1 is verified, and only 1 listing shows up in Map Maker?

    Is it safe to ignore this…?

    • Joy Hawkins

      Hey Reid,
      I’m not really sure what you’re describing is possible unless one is a Brand page or you have your address hidden. Would you be able to list the 2 pages?

  • Mark RD

    Thanks for the post Joy.
    Here’s my issue – I’ve got a Google Business page (call it PageA) that is verified, has about 100 followers and connected to my youtube channel. However it doesn’t show in the map results.
    Another Google Business page for my company (call it PageB) shows up very high in the map results – and I’ve just claimed ownership and awaiting the verification card. However this page has no followers and is not connected to my youtube channel.

    Once verified do I:
    a) keep both pages
    b) Make PageA a duplicate, remove it, lose followers and connect my youtube channel to PageB
    c) Make PageB (the one that is good in the map results) a duplicate, remove it – and hope PageA starts showing well in the map results.

    If you have any advice on this would be appreciated.

  • Google My Business Mails Verification Postcard to the Wrong Address: What to Do | LocalVisibilitySystem.com

    […] I did a consultation for a guy whose client – an HVAC contractor – had a problem with duplicate Google […]

  • Jerod Horch

    google has made this easier now. create a store code for each within the google my business center. no need to call anymore

  • Robert

    Hi Joy, can you share how to handle if you do in fact have multiple businesses at the same address?

    • Joy Hawkins

      Robert,

      It’s okay for there to be multiple businesses at the same address. You often find Starbucks inside Target, for example. When it becomes very problematic is when they are a similar type of business. You wouldn’t want the business categories they are using to be related at all.

  • Pilott

    Awesome article but question. My competitor who runs a face painting business as a service she doesn’t have a brick and motor. The catch is she currently created multiple business pages on Google. She used her 3 friends addresses 1) doctor office, 2. Amusement office, 3) friend location.

    Her pages has the same number on all of them, but hides the address and changed her business name on each page. Nky and Cincinnati face painting , balloons and face painting Cincinnati, fabulous faces, henna art Cincinnati.

    Is it against Google guidelines to do this? Even her links are different on the Google page but redirects to her main page.

    Thanks

  • Isma

    Hi Joy!

    I’m a little bit confused with the practitioner profiles. I have an active listing for the business, then i found a practitioner profile for the business owner (not verified).

    He’s not the only lawyer at the firm, so i’m assuming GMB team won’t merge or remove the practitioner profile for me.

    Talking about ranking, will this be an issue?

  • Erkan Yildiz

    Joy, excellent post – It certainly helped me to nail down some of my issues. But turns out the best way to solve the issue is to contact Google Advertisers community. I documented my findings here: http://persistlocalmarketing.com/merge-duplicate-google-local-business-listings/ Please feel free to use the info in your post if you find it useful

  • JW Fogal

    This is a very thorough and informative article. We have contacted google today and hope that our google maps nightmare will now come to an end. Thank you so much for this updated article. There are so many dated article that really offer no help at all. It’s amazing how google does not give more credibility to articles written more recently.

  • Tony Wang

    Thanks for the update Joy, but I recently tried to get a retired dentist listing moved to the new practice that took over but googlemybiz twitter support refused, saying that if he doesn’t work there, they won’t move it.

    I’m guessing twitter support is now run by the former phone support “specialists” 🙂

    • Joy Hawkins

      Tony,

      Can you clarify what you mean by the “new practice”. In the examples I’ve done, it was a retired practitioner and we moved it to the practice that he worked for before he retired (and no longer did).

  • Tony Wang

    The “new practice” bought the old one and kept same phone#/address, but changed the name. Even had the old domain forward to the new one. When you search the old name, the new practice shows in the knowledge panel.

    But when you search the old dr + city, the knowledge panel shows “old practice:old dr” listing. That’s the listing I was trying to get moved, which Google refused.

    In this case, I don’t think it’s hurting his ranking (which is lousy, but for other reasons), so I don’t know that it’s a big deal. They’re just hoping to catch old patients that may want to reconnect. I believe he retired 3 years ago, but if it were more recent I might be worried.

    So I guess this doesn’t exactly fit the scenarios you talked about. I was just surprised they wouldn’t mark it as moved. I suppose the “exception” they made in your example is easier to justify than the “exception” I was hoping for.

  • bog

    how long does it typically take to get the duplicate deleted after you’ve reported it to mapmaker?

    • Joy Hawkins

      Duplicates don’t get deleted, they get merged. You can get it accomplished faster by calling GMB. Reporting via MapMaker generally means you are waiting 4-10 weeks.

  • 4valleesfan

    Hello I manage more than one rental apartment in the same building. My competitors also have rental apartments in the same building. Mine are owned by different people and are very different (a 12-person luxury penthouse, and a small 4-person box). Google won’t publish the penthouse as the box is already live, and it tells me that they are duplicates. I have a total of 60 properties to rent in the same village and they are all in different locations apart from these two. Is there any way I can get the second one to show up? If I can only have one, I would rather it was the penthouse so how do i switch them? Thanks!

  • Elmer

    Hi Joy, I had a duplicate listing. Deleted the oldest one and got the newest one published. Now the older listing is still popping up (1 week after deletion) and the new one with status Published is not showing. Any ideas how come?

  • Lee Braham

    What about a service provider who changed their name and now has 2 listings. One old name, and second is correct name with formally known as?

  • Joseph

    Hey Joy, I used this article as a standard for helping remove duplicate GMB’s for my clients. Since MapMaker has been removed in December, do you have any intentions of updating the post? Sharing what works now?

    • Joy Hawkins

      Hey Joseph,

      Yes, I definitely am! I’ve been holding off until I see what features Google ends up adding to Google Maps. I figure they must be pushing some updates at some point in the next few weeks since MapMaker is toast in March. Once I see how that impacts things (if it does), I’ll update this post.

Leave a Reply

Send this to friend